In contemporary New York, a witty witch named Gillian finds herself smitten with her charming neighbor, but her feelings are complicated by her disdain for his fiancée. In a moment of mischief, she casts a spell to make him fall for her. However, as the enchantment unfolds, Gillian unexpectedly discovers her genuine feelings for him, leading to a delightful yet complicated love triangle that challenges her views on magic and romance.