Bill Benson and Ted Adams, set to star in a Broadway production, find themselves in Paris where they each meet their ideal leading lady. Unbeknownst to one another, both men promise their chosen actresses the coveted role. As they board a transatlantic liner to return home, the situation turns chaotic when they realize they’ve brought their respective picks with them. The journey becomes a comedic struggle as both must navigate the awkward task of revealing to their talented partners that their dreams of stardom may not come to fruition after all.