Investigative journalist Hannah Dunbar, at the pinnacle of her career, reflects on her past and the love she left behind, pondering her life with Ben a decade ago. When Santa Claus catches wind of her musings, he grants her a Christmas wish, whisking her away to an alternate reality where she and Ben are happily raising a family together. This unexpected journey forces Hannah to confront her choices and reconsider what truly defines happiness and fulfillment in her life.